The fuss regarding Shia traditions by those, who issue statements without
thinking1 is in excess. Some said that these traditions, are false writings attributed
to the hidden Imam and some said that they are false statements fabricated in the
names of Imam Muhammad Baqir and Imam Ja’far Sadiq (a.s.).2
Neither the first group fears consequences of false rumor nor the second
group is fearful of being exposed. At the end, these people emerge as liars, who
raised their heads in arrogance, severely denying these traditions, creating
mischief and issuing strange statements.
Abdullah Qaseemi has written in Saraa:3
“In fact, there are numerous liars among Shia tradition narrators and this is
due to greed for material wealth and proximity to its folks; or due to enmity to
tradition and Sunnah and malice to its folks. But Ahle Sunnat scholars have
mentioned the best reason…and among narrators of traditions from Ahle Sunnat
there is no one, who is blamed for fabrication and lying for the sake of material
greed and helping lusts and invalids beliefs.
Yes, among them there are people, who do not have a good memory or are
forgetful or are misunderstood and misinterpreted, but biographers have
mentioned all these people.”
Reply
The researcher will realize that these claims are hollow and there is no iota
of truth in them, and that majority of writers, who are given contract, write
falsehoods and allegations. And the criterion of politics is lying and inverting
facts, and many claims expressed about principles, views and beliefs, are illogical
statements and useless heresies, surrounded by false and deceptive statements.
There are people all over the world, whose needs are not fulfilled, except by
framing lies, fabricating traditions and deceiving simple people, dragging them to
paths of darkness and injustice.
If there was no warning of Allah, the Mighty and the High to the people that:
مَّا يَلْفِظُ مِن قَوْلٍ إِلَّا لَدَيْهِ رَقِيبٌ عَتِيدٌۭ (١٨)
“He utters not a word but there is by him a watcher at hand.”4
And if warnings revealed in the Book of Allah regarding every liar, who
makes allegations against woman, had not been there, none of these liars could
have said more than what they uttered or done what they did not do!
Each one of them is a greater liar than Kharafa and Hujina5.
Now, I want to inform you about the fact of the matter and reveal the secret
of this man about Ahle Sunnat narrators of traditions. He said:
“Among them there is no one, who may be accused of fabricating and
falsehood.”
Therefore, I present some people, who are indentified as fabricators and
liars, and some fabrications, which were resorted to for proximity to people or
following base desires or invalid beliefs are fabricated, so that you may yourself
see what their hands have wrought by making allegations against the sanctity of
Prophet and his Sunnah.
In this way, the matter would become clear for you and it may be final
statement of this discourse.