What can be said about one, who regards himself a jurist of Islam, and
before a large number of traditions including the authentic and good, and also
statements of companions and the consensus of Islamic Ummah, decides that
Ameerul Momineen (a.s.) is the heir of knowledge of Prophet and inspite of all
this, he overlooks all and believes that there is someone more knowledgeable
than Ameerul Momineen (a.s.) in the Islamic Ummah from companions, even in
this age!
What shall I say regarding one, who writes a book full of slanderous and
repulsive matter and entitles its Washia, who does not pay attention to the
repercussions of his behavior and cares not that he would be exposed and evil of
his act would be known to all?
On the contrary, he has spoiled the reputation of those to whom he
mentioned this. By writing this book, has exposed their own defects. Such that
critics remove the veil from his false statement and show to all that he was the
most dishonest writers of all times.
He says: “Umar was intelligent and knowledgeable person of his time. He
more learned than others as far as subjects of Quran and Sunnah were concerned.
In all his actions, throughout his life, he acted according to Quran and Sunnah.
He was aware of the position of prophetic traditions and understood the meanings
of Quran.”
We have chosen the following four foolish and meaningless statements of
this man from the part entitled: The rightly guided Caliphate.
However, what has come in majority of books does not support his view and
authentic history guides us to numerous instances that this person has turned
away from it. What is mentioned in this history takes us at distance from east to
the west from his view. History repeats for us the statement of Caliph, which he
says behind the curtain: That everyone, including ladies behind veils, are more
knowledgeable than Umar.
Now, I present writings and evidences to those, who are in pursuit of truth,
so that the reality is exposed.